
As a feminist who also loves television, I am constantly caught in a love-hate relationship with Sex and the City. On the one hand, it is a show that celebrates female friendships, sexuality, and independence, even if this celebration takes place in a decidedly unrealistic, television-like manner. On the other hand, it is a show that promotes consumerism, oppressive standards of beauty, and the quest for male attention at all costs. I don't think I would mind, except that SATC (as the journalists call it) is often held up as
a third-wave or post-feminist masterpiece or at least debated as such. The reason for this, I think, is that there are so few shows marketed to women that actually portray contemporary female characters (especially ones who are not supernatural in any way) that SATC is just about all we women have in terms of "feminist" programming.
At any rate, I lined up last week with hundreds of other women to see a midnight screening of Sex and the City: The Movie. I am not going to review the movie here, as that has already been done in myriad places throughout the information superhighway, including
this review by AV Club blogger Genevieve Koski. Suffice it to say, the movie met my expectations and I thought it was pretty much just like watching the television show, except with fancier outfits (and free popcorn!).
I wasn't going to post anything on this blog about the movie at all, since there is hype about it all over the place, but the experience of seeing it in the theater has been in my mind for the past several days. Never before have I been to such a large-scale event that was basically just for women. There were women and girls everywhere I looked, most of them dressed in their best approximations of SATC finery. As much as I felt a bit disgusted by some of the pseudo-feminism espoused by the show and its viewers, I also found myself getting swept away in a wave of girly excitement. We as women don't get very many media events, after all. SATC is the only recent movie I can think of with a practically all-woman cast, whereas I can think of several summer blockbusters that feature only men. What does this say about women? Where can we locate ourselves in this hot pink media blitz?
Unlike Carrie Bradshaw, I don't have a quick and clever answer to those questions. As a feminist, I want to watch Sex and the City because of its emphasis on the female, even if that emphasis is narrow and male-centric. As a television viewer, I want to watch Sex and the City because of the racy sex scenes and better-than-life wardrobes. It is my hope that the merging of these two parts of myself, which came together to watch SATC:TM, does not compromise my feminist ideology or my identity as a woman.
If I have learned anything about myself as a feminist up to this point, it is that being a feminist is confusing and full of contradictions. Is it wrong that, while part of me was appalled at the antics of the women in the movie theater last week, with their high heels and their highlights and their giggling, at the same time another part of me was loving every minute of it? I don't think so. I hope that we can all, as feminists, retain our ability to think critically while at the same time enjoying ourselves and our ability to celebrate in a room full of other women, even if the things we are celebrating are far from perfect.